Pulse.com.gh logo

Girl Smarts People on Reddit are buzzing about this weight-loss tool — but is it safe?

On Amazon, a simple search of “food scales” yields hundreds of results; on Reddit, it's hard to find dieters who aren't singing the scale's praises.

  • Published:
Do food scales help with weight loss play

Do food scales help with weight loss

(Photograph by Getty Images)

Whether you're trying to lose weight, counting your macros, or just trying your hand at portion control, you may have wondered if purchasing a food scale could really make a difference in your progress.

On Amazon, a simple search of “food scales” yields hundreds of results; on Reddit, it's hard to find dieters who aren't singing the scale's praises.

Here's how it works: On the back of any packaged food label is the food's serving size. While some packages share measurements in cups or tablespoons, you'll be hard-pressed to find one that doesn't show what a serving size of that food is in grams, or weight.

So, if you weigh your food before you eat it, you can determine exactly how many servings you're eating, as well as how many calories and grams of carbs, protein, and fat you're putting back. (Note: it's important to subtract the weight of whatever bowl you have your cereal in, for example, before you count the calories for three pounds worth of cereal.)

Meanwhile, if you're eating a non-packaged food like chicken or broccoli, you'll have to look online (like on the USDA's food database) to find how many grams are in a serving, and then how many calories and whatnot are in that serving (or however servings you end up eating).

But is it really necessary for weight loss? Registered dietitian Justine Roth, R.D., director of the nutrition department at the New York State Psychiatric Institute, isn't so sure.

“If you're a bodybuilder and you need your calories to be exact, a scale might be helpful to have more accuracy,” Roth says. “If someone feels like [using a scale] is a way to have an accurate sense of what they're eating, and they're in a healthy mindset, then I'm not against it.”

But in Roth's clinical experience, for many clients using a food scale can be counterproductive or even dangerous. (Speed up your progress towards your weight-loss goals with Women's Health's Look Better Naked DVD.)

“I think there's a very small number of people who can do this without becoming obsessive,” she says. Consider all the work that using a food scale involves, and it's easy to see how obsession could be one not-so-fun side effect. Roth, who primarily counsels patients with disordered eating, says that often using a scale can backfire when patients restrict themselves and then binge later.

“There's this idea that losing weight is a perfect science, and really it's not,” she says. “In reality, you can get there without being obsessive. When you're filling your body with natural, good foods, you'll lose weight. If you eat a lot of processed foods and huge portions, you'll gain.”

These "healthy" foods are actually bad for you:

Many people, however, insist that a food scale is a better way to ensure accuracy with portion sizes—and they're not wrong. A 2013 study published in the journal Obesity showed that many labels on processed snack foods contained more calories in actuality than it claimed on the package.

“When I had patients who were distrusting of food labels, I was like, yeah, because they're not true,” Roth says. “What are the odds that every food will have an exact ounce or an exact calorie?”

Instead of becoming a “slave to the scale,” Roth suggests to her clients a less-obsessive (and less-accurate) way of portioning food: Using a regular, 10-inch dinner plate as a template, each portion of a meal should take up roughly one-third of the plate and include proteins, starches, and vegetables. Reasonable portion control using these benchmarks is often more psychologically healthy for clients than using scales, according to Roth.

“If you adapt to a healthy lifestyle, then you will see changes,” Roth says. “Unless you're baking, using a scale just isn't necessary.”

Do you ever witness news or have a story that should be featured on Pulse Ghana?
Submit your stories, pictures and videos to us now via WhatsApp: +233507713497, Social Media @pulseghana: #PulseEyewitness & DM or Email: eyewitness@pulse.com.gh.

Recommended Articles

Recommended Videos

Top Articles

1 Girl Smarts How to deal with suicidal thoughts — From 7 women who’ve...bullet
2 Health Tips 6 legit health and beauty benefits of baking sodabullet
3 Fitness This quickie workout is perfect for when you can't get to...bullet
4 Girl Smarts 'Activewear companies, I know you're afraid of...bullet
5 Girl Smarts 7 blood clot symptoms you should never ignorebullet
6 Girl Smarts Carrie underwood worried people would mistake her...bullet
7 Health Tips 10 reasons you’ve got bumps on your vaginabullet
8 Girl Smarts Inside the creepy world of women selling you...bullet
9 Relationship Talk Jana Kramer just posted photos...bullet
10 Girl Smarts 12 reasons why you're suddenly so bloatedbullet

Top Videos

1 Sexual comfort Sex positions women hatebullet
2 Girl Smarts Carrie underwood worried people would mistake her face...bullet
3 Baby Boy Just Couldn't Wait!bullet
4 Girl Smarts Rihanna just gave Anne Hathaway the best compliment...bullet
5 Girl Smarts The new trailer for season 15 of 'Grey's Anatomy'...bullet
6 Odd Enough This doctor spotted a woman’s cancerous neck lump...bullet
7 Girl Smarts Everything new on Netflix in July 2018bullet
8 Women Sex Health 5 reasons women don't always have orgasmsbullet
9 Health Threats oral sex/cunnilingus pose to the vaginabullet

Womens Health